I am asked that question all the time. Might be because those who know me will tell you I am a pie-aholic. If you know of a place I have not tried please email. One can never have enough pie!
Gardner Pie Co.
191 Logan Ave., Barberton, OH
330.245.2030
website
Summit County
Mama Jo Homestyle Pies
Amherst Plaza, Amherst 440.960.7437
Lorain County
Medina Shopping Plaza Medina, OH 330.722.7437
Medina County
website
Amish Owned Countryside Home Bakery
17075 Mumford Rd, Burton
Geauga County
Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen
14743 Old State Rd, Middlefield, OH
440.632.9361
website
Geauga County
Hartville Kitchen - website
1015 Edison St., NW, Hartville, OH 330.877.9353
Summit County
Troyers Home Pantry - website
668 W. Main, Apple Creek and 317 E. North Street Wooster
Wayne County
Gray House Pies
26075 Detroit Rd., Westlake, OH
440.360.7870
website
Cuyahoga County
Schmucker’s
2103 N. Reynolds Road, Toledo, OH
419.535.9116
website
Lucas County
Dutch Valley Bakery & Cafe
Walnut Creek and Sugarcreek
website
Holmes County